B2Shift · Published · Updated

All three connect apps and move data between them; the differences that matter show up once a workflow gets past the simple, linear case.

Zapier: fastest to a simple result

Zapier has the largest app catalogue and the simplest mental model — trigger, then steps. It's a strong choice for straightforward, linear automations maintained by non-technical staff. It becomes limiting once a workflow needs complex branching logic, self-hosting, or high-volume, low-cost execution; pricing scales with task volume, which is worth modelling before committing at scale.

Make (formerly Integromat): more control, steeper learning curve

Make's visual, graph-based builder supports more complex branching and iteration than Zapier's linear model, at the cost of a steeper learning curve for whoever maintains it. It's a reasonable middle ground when a workflow needs real conditional logic but self-hosting isn't a requirement.

n8n: the choice when self-hosting or EU data residency matters

n8n is source-available and can be self-hosted, which matters directly for teams with data-residency requirements or a preference against sending workflow data through a third party's cloud. It supports custom code nodes for logic the visual builders can't express, at the cost of needing someone comfortable maintaining infrastructure if self-hosted. The managed cloud option removes that overhead if self-hosting isn't a priority.

What actually decides it

Volume and cost model matter more than most comparisons admit — task-based pricing (Zapier, Make) behaves very differently at 500 executions a month versus 50,000. Data residency and self-hosting requirements point toward n8n. Branching complexity favours Make or n8n over Zapier. And who maintains it afterwards is often the deciding factor: a tool your team can actually operate beats a technically superior one nobody understands six months after launch. See Workflow Automation & Integrations for how we typically combine one of these with direct API integrations rather than relying on a single tool for everything.

Compare the billing unit, not just the plan price

n8n, Make and Zapier can all move a lead from a form into a CRM and notify a salesperson, but their usage units are different. n8n's hosted plans count workflow executions, regardless of workflow complexity. Make counts credits consumed by scenario module actions; most non-AI actions use one credit, while some AI features can use more. Zapier counts successful task-consuming actions, and its task rates vary for some AI and programmatic steps. A monthly allowance therefore cannot be compared by number alone.

The table is a dated snapshot of official public plan pages checked on 15 October 2026. Prices depend on billing period, currency, account location, plan and usage tier. Treat them as orientation, not a quote; open the provider's pricing page and confirm the billing selector before purchasing. The more durable comparison is how each tool counts a workflow run and what operating responsibility it leaves with your team.

Published plan snapshot checked 15 October 2026; confirm live terms before purchase
PlatformUsage unitPublished entry exampleOperational trade-off
n8n CloudOne workflow execution, regardless of stepsStarter: €20/month billed annually for 2,500 executionsHosted operation is simpler; self-hosting offers control but makes your team responsible for infrastructure and upgrades.
MakeCredits per module action; some AI features varyCore page shows $12/month for 10,000 credits; check billing toggleVisual scenarios and routers are flexible; estimate every module action and plan for credit exhaustion.
ZapierTasks for successful actions; some AI/code rates varyFree: 100 tasks/month; Professional starts at $19.99/monthBroad app coverage and quick setup; count successful actions and decide how to handle paid overages or paused workflows.

Same workflow, different usage arithmetic

Consider a small lead-routing workflow: a form submission triggers the automation, the record is checked, a CRM lead is created, a Slack message is sent, and a follow-up task is created. If the process receives 1,000 submissions in a month and each run completes the three listed actions, the rough count is 1,000 n8n executions, about 3,000 Make credits for three one-credit module actions, or about 3,000 Zapier tasks for three successful action steps. The trigger itself is not counted as a Zapier task on the current pricing help page.

This is an estimate of platform usage, not a claim that the three bills will be equal. A real design may add searches, filters, error handlers, loops, retries, AI classification or multiple actions. In Make, those modules can add credits, although routers and some error-handler modules are excluded. In Zapier, unsuccessful actions do not count, but some AI or code usage can have a different task rate. In n8n, the run remains one execution even when it contains more steps, but hosting, concurrency and maintenance still matter.

Build a small usage ledger before selecting a plan: list each trigger, search, write, notification, loop and AI step; note how often the trigger is checked; then multiply by measured monthly volume. Add a separate high-volume month and a failure/replay allowance based on observed behavior. Do not assume every platform counts a polling check, failed step or AI operation the same way. Use the provider's current definition and a sample execution history to validate the estimate.

How n8n, Make and Zapier differ in practice

Choose n8n when execution-based pricing, technical control or self-hosting is important and someone on the team can own deployment, secrets, backups, upgrades and recovery. Its hosted plan reduces infrastructure work, while the self-hosted Community Edition shifts that operational responsibility to you. Self-hosting is not automatically cheaper once engineering and on-call time are counted.

Choose Make when the team benefits from a visual scenario builder with branching and data transformation, and the workflow's module count can be forecast. Map actions per run before estimating monthly credits. Consider what happens at the credit limit: Make says scenarios stop until credits are added, while webhook events may queue within available capacity. That pause behavior should be part of an operational plan.

Choose Zapier when the required connectors and setup speed matter most, especially for straightforward workflows maintained by non-developers. Count each successful task-consuming action, not just the number of Zaps. The current pricing page describes overage billing as optional and workflows can pause if it is disabled; choose the behavior deliberately so a task limit does not surprise the team.

Run a fair proof of concept

Build the same narrow process in each shortlisted tool. Use the same sample input, field mapping, duplicate rule, exception path, logging requirement and monthly volume. Measure setup time, effort to change a field, time to diagnose a failed run, and the clarity of the hand-off to the process owner. Count actions or modules from the actual run history rather than guessing from the diagram.

Test at least four failure cases: invalid input, duplicate event, destination API unavailable and expired connection. Confirm whether each platform retries, pauses, queues or reports the error, and whether replaying an item can create a duplicate. A quick happy-path example does not answer these operational questions. Record what happens and who would notice it at 9 a.m. on a workday.

A short decision checklist

Before committing, verify that every required app action exists in the plan you intend to buy, that the relevant data can be accessed under your security policy, and that the usage unit matches your forecast. Ask who maintains credentials, monitors failed runs, owns workflow changes and can export the configuration if the team switches tools. Include the value of internal maintenance when comparing a hosted subscription with self-hosting.

There is no universal winner. Start with the process, its exception rate and the people who will own it. Then choose the least complex platform that meets the integration, control, cost and support requirements. If two tools fit, run the same pilot in both and decide on observed reliability and total operating effort, not a feature checklist alone.

  • Can the plan access every required app action, event trigger and field?
  • Does the platform meet deployment, identity, logging and retention requirements?
  • Have you estimated its actual billing unit from realistic runs and exception paths?
  • Who will monitor failures, rotate credentials, approve changes and own an exit?

Check constraints before you build a comparison

A tool can be ruled out by a requirement that has nothing to do with its headline plan. Confirm whether the exact app actions and event triggers exist, whether a private or self-hosted deployment is required, what identity and permission controls are available, and how long execution logs are retained. Check rate limits, file size limits, concurrency and the way credentials are rotated. Verify these details against the current plan and product documentation; plan features change and may differ by tier.

Then make ownership explicit. A self-hosted system needs someone to patch the host, restore backups, monitor capacity and respond to outages. A hosted system still needs an owner for credentials, workflow changes, exception queues and vendor escalation. If no one can own these tasks, include managed support in the total cost or choose a narrower process that the current team can operate safely.

Sources

n8n — Plans and pricing

Make — Pricing

Zapier — Pricing

Zapier — Task usage rates

Discuss your workflow